DEFY AND DENY – Korakh – Num. 16:1–17:15 –- by Rabbi Baruch Cohon

Screen Shot 2013-11-05 at 11.26.08 AM

DEFY AND DENY – Korakh – Num. 16:1–17:15 –- by Rabbi Baruch Cohon

The rebellion against Moses’ leadership and Aaron’s priesthood, led by a hitherto unknown man named Korakh, has to be one of the most difficult stories in the Torah. Coming right after the failed expedition of the spies, it recounts a fellow Levite’s challenge to the authority of the two men who led the Israelite people out of slavery. Accompanied by members of the tribe of Reuben who apparently were seeking to restore the status of their ancestor as the oldest son and therefore the heir of father Jacob, Korakh and his henchmen defy Moses and Aaron, deny their right to lead, and urge the people to depose them. The confrontation results in the kind of miraculous punishment that other rebels never got. The earth opens and devours Korakh and his followers. Only Moses’ prayer saves the rest of the people. And Aaron’s position is validated by a different kind of miracle, when his wooden staff, representing the tribe of Levi, was placed in the Tabernacle overnight along with staffs of the other 11 tribes. The next morning, all the staffs were still there exactly as they were the night before – except Aaron’s staff which had sprouted leaves, blossoms and almonds. The fruit of blessing!

Supernatural events, whether fatal or inspiring, are not all that make this story difficult. Considered from the vantage point of centuries of Jewish history, this is one extreme example of the disunity that plagues us. “Two Jews, three opinions” is no longer a joke. Sometimes we may wonder how the ancient kingdom of Israel managed to field a disciplined dedicated army to defeat its foes. Didn’t any of the soldiers object to taking orders? Just as well, how does the modern State of Israel marshal its martial forces? Should we expect some upstart lieutenant-colonel to proclaim himself a general and attempt to replace his commander? Or will we soon hear about the captain of a destroyer changing his ordered course and sailing off to Greece? If anything like that happened, there would likely be military penalties. But not a sudden sinkhole to wipe out the offender and all his crew. In our time, with the communications we have today, our enemies are doing their best to dig a much deeper sinkhole. A sinkhole for all the Jewish people. Jewish disunity only helps that effort.

If we take a real interest in our future – whether in America, Israel, Europe, Asia or anywhere else – we need to learn a lesson from the story of Korakh. Two significant lines underscore the message of the Korakh story.

One line comes in the prayer of Moses and Aaron: “Shall one man sin, and G-d turn in anger on the whole community?” We may be responsible for each other, we can and should support each other, but we are first responsible for our own actions. Korakh was the sinner; yet not all the people listened to him. We can disagree, and still share a great heritage and a great destiny.

The other line we will read three weeks from this Sabbath, in Parsha Pinkhas. In just four words, the Torah notes: “Uv’nai Korakh lo maisu — Korakh’s children did not die.” In fact, no less than 11 of the Psalms of David are credited to his descendants. They occupied a place in the Sanctuary as a Levitic family. And we still recite psalms today that begin with the words “A song of the Sons of Korakh.” We need not pass our mistakes along to future generations. Significantly, this message is exactly opposite to Shakespeare’s line: “The evil that men do lives after them; the good is oft interred with their bones.” Not in Judaism. Korakh’s children did not die. They do not share his guilt. We can learn from Korakh that we always have hope.

Ken y’hee rotzon.

This entry was posted in Jewish Blogs and tagged , , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

2 Responses to DEFY AND DENY – Korakh – Num. 16:1–17:15 –- by Rabbi Baruch Cohon

  1. Allie Pressman says:

    I find it difficult to find meanings in your Torah Blogs, with all the hatred and mayhem that is going on in our country. Is religion the answer? So far, in my eyes, I see no understanding and caring for each other. Will there be a future with a light at the end of the tunnel.

  2. Baruch says:

    Dear Allie,
    What our ancestors envisioned as the light at the end of the tunnel is what they called “Moshiach tzyten.” A Messianic age would bring the understanding and care you seek — we all seek. Of course they didn’t just sit and wait for that age, and neither can we. One tradition says the Moshiach will arrive when the world is 100% evil, and another says he will come when the world is 100% good. Not likely either way. So we need to make our own Messianic age, and that means striking a balance between resisting evil and cultivating goodness. We must not tolerate the hatred and mayhem you refer to, in fact we must look for allies to help prevent more mass killings, to expose and punish anti-Semitic outbreaks and policies, to counter destructive and violent attitudes toward immigrants, etc. We have some allies like that, and they are in the religious community, both Jewish and Christian. One group I happen to know about is the Israel-Christian Nexus which represents more than a million church members and many thousands of votes. Just an example.

Comments are closed.