LAWS AND ORDERS – Mishpatim, Ex. 21-24 – by Rabbi Baruch Cohon

Screen Shot 2013-11-05 at 11.26.08 AM

LAWS AND ORDERS – Mishpatim, Ex. 21-24 – by Rabbi Baruch Cohon

          Last week’s Torah reading gave us principles of right and wrong in the Ten Commandments.  This week we go into detail with a basic code of law — what to do, what not to do, and the penalties for violating the laws. 

          Every civilization seems to come up with some kind of law code, with accompanying penalties.   What sets Mishpatim apart?  Let’s take some examples.

          One distinguishing feature, of course, is the Eternal basis of these laws.   Justice is not limited to the people of Israel.  It applies to everyone in Israel’s borders.  Historically, non-Jews residing in the country were not responsible for all the 613 commandments of the Torah, but they were held responsible for the “commandments of the children of Noah” – just 7 total.  So foreign immigrants (legal or otherwise) had some duties.  But they also had rights.  The Sabbath law here in Mishpatim specifically includes them, saying “rest on the seventh day … and let the stranger also be refreshed.”  Just a few sentences earlier we read: “Do not oppress (read “discriminate against”) a stranger, for you know the heart of a stranger because you were strangers in the land of Egypt.” 

          Another remarkable law concerns treatment of domestic animals.  If you see your enemy’s donkey – or any beast belonging to someone else – collapsing under a heavy burden, would you ignore that creature?  Never mind who his owner is.   Help him!  Take some of that load off and let the poor donkey stand up!   Kindness to animals comes right alongside the list of the holy days and their observance.

          Just a word about penalties.  Archeology of Biblical period buildings uncovers no big prisons.  A holding cell here or there is about all.  As we read here, and elsewhere in Torah and Talmud, penalties for breaking the law included execution, banishment, flogging, and economic punishment.  Even the famous “eye for an eye” statute enunciated here was interpreted as economic penalty – the value of an eye or of a tooth. Including the law to release an indentured servant if the master knocked out that tooth. Our ancestors didn’t have to come up with huge amounts of public money to support long-term prisoners.  What they did have to do was re-try a convicted offender if new evidence can prove him innocent.  Of course they could do that only if the offender was still alive.  But this law accepts the validity of new evidence.

          And they didn’t even have DNA. 

          For more examples of Torah justice, read the section.  We and our courts could learn from it today!

Posted in 613 mitzvos, Baruch Cohon, Exodus, Jewish, Jewish Blogs, Jewish Law, Mishpatim, Ten Commandments, Torah, Torah commandment, Torah Study | Tagged , , , , , , | 1 Comment

WHO IS JETHRO? – Yitro, Ex.18-20 – by Rabbi Baruch Cohon

Screen Shot 2013-11-05 at 11.26.08 AM

WHO IS JETHRO? – Yitro, Ex.18-20 – by Rabbi Baruch Cohon

          Of the five books of the Torah, the figure of Moses dominates four.  His birth, his youth in the palace, his rediscovery of his people’s pain, and the hot temper that caused him to kill the brutal taskmaster and prompted a break with Pharoah and flight to the desert, all lead to his marriage to Zipporah, daughter of Jethro, the heathen priest of Midian.  (What? Did Moses marry a shiksa? Well, yes, but remember, this “intermarriage” took place before Israel received the Torah.)  Apparently drawn to Moses both for his physical strength – rolling the stone off the well single handed – and for the power of his faith in the One G-d, Zipporah is the one who circumcises her infant son when Moses misses the proper date.  They have two sons, Gershom and Eliezer.  Those Hebrew names remain popular among Jewish families ever since, but the original men do not figure in their people’s history.   No books are named for them.  They never lived in slavery, they did not experience the Exodus, and neither did their mother.   Perhaps angry at Zipporah for usurping his right of milah for his son, Moses sent her and the boys to her father while he returned to Egypt.  There’s that temper again.

          Moses is called Moshe Rabbeynu – Moses our teacher, our lawgiver, the man who brought us to Mount Sinai for the ultimate revelation.  Rightly has it been observed that this revelation did not appear to one individual who then preached it to his people.  It was revealed to the entire people – some two million of them – and Judaism is the only one of all the world religions that proceeds from this kind of revelation.  That is the scene described in this week’s Torah reading. 

          Now every week’s Torah reading has a Hebrew name.  And what name does this week’s reading bear?  This reading includes the national preparations, the thunder and lightning on the mountain, the Voice of G-d communicating the Ten Commandments. Is it named for Moses?  No sir.  It bears the name Yitro – Jethro, Moses’ father-in-law, the heathen priest of Midian.  How does he rate?

          Well, here we learn that while he did not see the Exodus, he heard about it and took it to heart.  He realized that not only was the Egyptian army submerged, but the idols of Egypt showed up powerless.  Only the One G-d inspired triumph.  So Jethro enters this week’s narrative bringing both his own newly acquired reverence for his son-in-law’s faith, and the daughter and grandsons whom he has been sheltering, to reunite Moses’ family.  As the story progresses, Jethro offers Moses very practical advice on how to administer these twelve unruly tribes.  After this productive visit, Moses sends Jethro home.  Why?  Rashi says Jethro was to go and convert the rest of his family to Judaism.

          So when Israel receives the Torah at Mount Sinai, Jethro is not there.  Yet he gives his name to this Sedrah, as a helper and motivator.  And indeed that is how we remember him these thousands of years later, as a devoted family man, as a man with high intelligence and an open mind, as a man who did not hear the Ten Commandments spoken from On High but could detail the difference between right and wrong.        

          Today, the Big Ten may be “politically incorrect” in some places – gotta censor the Divine out of any public displays, we are told – but their message of right and wrong still rings true.  Like Jethro, let those who recognize their value be remembered and respected.

Posted in Exodus, Jewish Blogs, Torah, Torah Study | Tagged , , , , , , , | Comments Off on WHO IS JETHRO? – Yitro, Ex.18-20 – by Rabbi Baruch Cohon

ISRAEL WILL SING – Ex.15, Shabat Shirah – by Rabbi Baruch Cohon

Screen Shot 2013-11-05 at 11.26.08 AM

ISRAEL WILL SING – Ex.15, Shabat Shirah – by Rabbi Baruch Cohon

          This week we observe the annual Sabbath of Song, when the Torah reader intones the jubilant Song of Moses with its special melody – a paean of gratitude and joy, celebrating the Israelites crossing the Red Sea on dry land, and reaching freedom after centuries of Egyptian slavery.  Pursuing forces sank under the returning waves.  Just a year or two ago, modern archeologists discovered some gold wheel-covers of Pharaoh’s chariots in the Red Sea’s sands.  Yes, it happened.  Moses had plenty to sing about.

          Shirat haYam – the Song of the Sea – prompts the name of this special Sabbath, called Shabat Shirah – the Sabbath of Song.  This week many congregations will hold concerts of Jewish music, and feature musical services, encouraging and rewarding the work of contemporary Jewish composers.  I look forward to attending a service like that at the synagogue that I served for many years, where my former student is now Cantor and will perform a composition of mine.  Indeed, music and song play a huge role in our lives.   Biblically, this Song of Moses is just the first of the great songs.  In the Book of Numbers we read the people’s song of elation at finding a well in the desert.  In Deuteronomy, one of the last acts of Moses is to voice his testament, Haazinu, “in the ears of the whole community of Israel, the words of this song:

Listen, you heavens, and I will speak,

and let the earth hear the utterance of my mouth…”       

          Prophets and kings continue the poetry and the music.  Take Deborah’s song in the book of Judges (this week’s Haftorah), others in Second Samuel, in Isaiah, and of course in the Psalms of David.  The very last of those Psalms, #150 details a virtual catalogue of the musical instruments the Levites played in the Sanctuary to accompany dance and the human voice.  Then Solomon gave us the Song of Songs, an ultimate love song, which our tradition takes symbolically as expressing the love of G-d and Israel.

          So the power of song sparks our lives.  The Mechilta counts 10 important songs, the first being the Song of the Sea, and the last being the song we will sing with the Messiah when he arrives.  That, says this Midrash, will be the eternal song.

          But before leaving those exultant singers on the east shore of the Red Sea – Moses leading the men and Miriam leading the women – let’s look at one grammatic curiosity.  The Torah does not say Az shar Moshe uv’ney Yisrael – “then Moses and the Israelites sang.”  It says Az yashir Moshe – literally “then Moses and the Israelites will sing.”  When all slaves will be freed, when hatred and oppression will be drowned, when human life will be fulfilled and not polluted – we will all sing.   That is what we hope for.  That is what we sing about.  With the Messiah, with our neighbors, with each other.

          Join the chorus!

Posted in Baruch Cohon, Cantor, Exodus, Jewish, Jewish Blogs, Shabat Shira - The Sabbath of Song, Torah Study | Tagged , , , , , , | 1 Comment

MY PLAGUES, OR YOURS – Exodus 6-10 – by Rabbi Baruch Cohon

Screen Shot 2013-11-05 at 11.26.08 AM

MY PLAGUES, OR YOURS – Exodus 6-10 – by Rabbi Baruch Cohon                 

          The famous 10 plagues of Egypt bring a story of disaster and suffering to the Torah readings of these two weeks.  Just their names are frightful:  Blood, frogs, lice, wild animals, murrain, boils, hail, locusts, darkness, and death of the firstborn.  All that’s missing is terrorism.  At our Passover Seder we will spill out a drop of wine for each of them, to witness that even now we diminish our celebration to remember the pain of our enemies.

          Many scholars discussed the significance and reality of these plagues.  Did things like this actually happen in Egypt?  Or is this whole sequence told just to illustrate the haughty stubborn duplicitous personality of Pharaoh and why he brought such calamities on his people? 

          One aspect of the Plagues story sometimes eludes us.  The first three plagues happen to all the residents of Egypt, including the Israelites.   When the Nile water turns to blood, they all have to dig and scrounge for drinking water.  Frogs invade Jewish houses in Goshen just as they do the Pharaoh’s palace.  And everyone scratches the bites of the lice.  No wonder Pharaoh doesn’t give up. 

          Then mixed groups of wild animals invade Egyptian farms and homes, and leave the Hebrews alone.  Now something changes.  Instead of challenging his sorcerers to duplicate the evil spell, Pharaoh tells Moses and Aaron to “take your people and go worship your G-d.”  Of course, being Pharaoh, he changes his mind as soon as the plague stops.  Three more scourges produce the same results. 

By the time #8 is threatened – locusts to devour their crops – Pharaoh’s officers and sorcerers speak up: “Don’t you know by now that Egypt is perishing?”  Since absolute power listens to no one, Pharaoh dismisses them.  But in so doing he ignores a salient truth, just as true today as it was in ancient Egypt.  When bad things happen to you and to me, it’s a disaster.  Cope with it.  But when they happen to me – and notto you – it’s a plague.  A dire signal.  Learn something.  Don’t wait through seven warnings like the Egyptian courtiers.  And don’t depend on a too-powerful government to solve your problems.  If you have idols, break them.  If you have an epidemic (say HIV for example), find a remedy — even if it means changing some of your habits.  If you have an addiction, get into recovery; help is available.

And if you have slaves, physical or emotional, set them free.

Posted in Jewish Blogs | Tagged , , , , , , , , | Comments Off on MY PLAGUES, OR YOURS – Exodus 6-10 – by Rabbi Baruch Cohon

OF THE HEBREWS’ CHILDREN – Shmot – by Rabbi Baruch Cohon

Screen Shot 2013-11-05 at 11.26.08 AM

OF THE HEBREWS’ CHILDREN – Shmot – Ex.1:1-6:1 by Rabbi Baruch Cohon

          Genocide is nothing new.  Pharaoh of Egypt was mandating a gradual genocide of his Israelite slaves when he decreed that all male Hebrew babies would be drowned in the Nile.  Moses’ mother hid her infant son as long as she could, then put him in a basket and floated him in the river while his sister Miriam watched his progress from the bank.

          Enter Pharaoh’s daughter, come for a dip.  Finding the boy in the basket, she picks him up, looks him over and observes “mi-yal-dey ha-ivrim zeh – this is one of the Hebrews’ children.”   How does she know?

          Commentators offer lofty reasons, like the sacred beauty that shines around little Moses, or the fact that the Torah describes him as na-ar – a youth – rather than ti-nok – a baby – or even yeled – a small boy.   As young as he was, they suggest, he already behaved as if he was half grown.  It remained for Ibn Ezra to cite a rather obvious reason: he was ma-hul – circumcised.  Although some writers, like the modern commentator Rabbi Gunther Plaut, suggest that Egyptians might have circumcised their sons too, we have no such record in the Torah.  Circumcision was, and remained, the Jewish trademark.

          Today that trademark is under attack.   Contradicting scientific evidence that circumcised men are freer of some diseases, some liberal governments are prohibiting the process when done for religious or other non-medical reasons. Finally, here is one issue that Jews and Muslims agree on.  True, we do the operation at very different ages – 8 days vs. 13 years.  One mohel told me that at 8 days the child is least sensitive to pain.  No wonder Arab boys are sent to an isolated camp when their turn comes.  Maybe that’s how they train suicide bombers?  In any case, both Jewish and Muslim authorities are challenging these pseudo-humanitarian laws in countries like Holland and Denmark, and fighting their consideration in some American states. 

          In the past, it was reported that the British royal family had all their male babies circumcised by a mohel.  After all, if you want a specialist, he’s it.  What about the new little prince?  So far, no one from England that I have asked knows for sure, but it would be quite interesting to confirm just what operation, if any, young Prince George had – particularly since his mother has some Jewish ancestry.

          I would welcome any facts that are out there.

Posted in Baruch Cohon, Circumcision, Exodus, Jewish, Jewish Blogs, Jewish Traditions, Torah, Torah Study | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , | Comments Off on OF THE HEBREWS’ CHILDREN – Shmot – by Rabbi Baruch Cohon